A couple of weeks ago, Andrew and I overheard, just before the race began, an announcer for a kids’ triathlon say, through his megaphone, “Everyone’s a winner, just for showing up!” I cringed. Yes, those kids were awesome for showing up and should be proud of themselves. Yes, most of them probably worked really hard training and woke up early and showed motivation to be athletic and active and competitive. But in this case, the winner was the kid who swam, biked, and ran the fastest. The winner was the kid who crossed the finish line first.
While I certainly believe that winning isn’t everything*, I also feel that it is important for kids to understand the concept of it, to feel the joy and pride that comes from winning at something at which they have worked hard and persisted. And to feel disappointment every once in a while when they don’t. I am probably the furthest thing from a “tiger mom,” pushing her kids to excel and win and study and be the best always the best. And yet, I recognize that in some circumstances, my children will be competing against others, and there will inevitably be a winner. I want my children to feel the sting of defeat just as much as I want them to feel the joy of triumph. I also want them to learn how to lose gracefully, show good sportsmanship, pick themselves back up, persist, and persevere. And I don’t think they should receive awards, trophies, or consolation prizes when they lose. Our children can and should handle disappointment as a simple rite of being human.
I recently wrote an article about it here. How do you feel about the debate? Should every child be told he/she is a winner just for showing up?
*I also realized, too late, that I conveyed that I thought 2nd or 3rd place was somehow “losing,” which of course I didn’t intend. Of course children should be proud of themselves for placing, or for trying their hardest… of course they should be having fun, of course they learn tons of things from competing or just playing sports. End rant.


























